Whatta Catch Sport Fishing has run a full-service charter boat out of Mill Basin, Brooklyn, New York since 1997, led by Captains John Calamia, Rob Miglino, and Joe, who together bring more than 50-75 years of combined experience fishing local waters since they were kids. All three captains hold a Master 100-Ton License and give 100% dedication to every charter, ensuring a safe, enjoyable, and successful day on the water.
The business fishes all species of saltwater fish in season, including Striped Bass, Fluke, Flounder, Sea Bass, Porgies, Sharks, and Tuna, with fishing grounds ranging from Jamaica Bay all the way to the Hudson Canyon depending on the target species. Day and night, full and half-day charters are all available. The Whatta Catch herself is a custom-built 40-foot H&H, equipped with the latest electronics and safety equipment, including a generator for an extra measure of safety, plus a spacious cockpit giving everyone plenty of room at the rail.
The business is genuinely family-friendly, welcoming children aboard, and is also available for fishing tournaments and corporate outings, catering to beginners and experienced anglers alike.
With reviews across multiple platforms averaging around 4-4.5 stars (3.9 on this listing, 10 reviews), guests consistently praise the captains’ professionalism, top-notch gear, and knowledge of good fishing spots, particularly for striped bass.
For anglers and families looking for an experienced, multi-captain, year-round fishing charter out of Mill Basin, Brooklyn, targeting everything from local Jamaica Bay species to offshore Tuna, Whatta Catch Sport Fishing offers a well-established operation with nearly three decades in business.
